What to do with garage sale leftovers in Indianapolis
By Rory at Estate Sale Zone · Published
Written, edited and reviewed by Rory before publishing. How we make guides
After a sale in Indianapolis, give what's left to neighbors through a Buy Nothing group, book a free charity or city pickup, or take it to a drop-off. Each option below links to the organization's own page, with the date we last checked it. Hours and rules change, so check before you go.
Give it away to neighbors
Buy Nothing groups are for giving things to neighbors, free. Selling, trading and advertising aren't allowed, so post each thing as a gift rather than promoting your sale. You join the group for where you live.
Buy Nothing Project (local gift groups and app)Free
Neighbors give things away for free. No selling, trading, bartering, advertising or marketing, so it suits leftovers you'd give away, not promoting a sale.
Join through the Buy Nothing app (share with people nearby), or create a Buy Nothing account, go to Settings and pick your official local Facebook group from 'Registered Buy Nothing Groups'.
Checked October 10, 2026 on their own page
Pickup from your home
Greater Indy Habitat ReStore: free donation pickupFree
Habitat picks up usable furniture and appliances for free, and items must be in good condition and full working order.
Call the ReStore donations line or schedule on the ReStore page; trucks run every day except Sunday, typically 10 a.m. to 5 p.m.
Checked November 18, 2026 on their own page
St. Vincent de Paul Indianapolis: free furniture pickup and drop-offFree
SVdP picks up furniture and boxed household goods it can give away or resell, usually within 2 weeks, and items must be on the main level, in a garage or outside.
Call 317-687-1006 to schedule, or drop off at 1201 Maryland Street, Dock Door 3, Monday to Saturday 9 a.m. to 3 p.m.
Checked November 18, 2026 on their own page
City of Anderson: heavy pick-upCost varies
For homes in Anderson
Anderson's hauler picks up furniture and appliances too big for the cart, but not anything with Freon, remodeling debris or move-out trash.
Call Best Way Disposal at 765-649-7272 to set up a pickup for the day after your trash day.
Checked November 18, 2026 on their own page
City of Greenwood: monthly heavy trashCost varies
For homes in Greenwood
Greenwood collects furniture, wrapped mattresses and non-Freon appliances once a month, and Freon appliances cost $75.
Set items out on your regular trash day in the last full week of the month, or call Best Way at 317-484-3365 for a Freon appliance.
Checked November 18, 2026 on their own page
City of Indianapolis: heavy trash pickupFree
For homes in Indianapolis
On your heavy trash day you can set up to two bulky items a month next to your cart, such as furniture, mattresses and appliances without Freon; TVs and construction debris are not taken.
Look up your heavy trash day on indy.gov and set the items by your cart that day; for a fridge or other appliance with Freon, contact the Mayor's Action Center to arrange pickup.
Checked November 18, 2026 on their own page
City of Westfield: Bulk Trash DayCost varies
For homes in Westfield
Westfield holds a drop-off day twice a year, with fees of $5 per wrapped mattress, $30 per Freon appliance and $20 per TV or computer.
Bring items to Westfield City Services, 2728 E. 171st Street, on the second Saturday in May or October, 8 a.m. to 12 p.m.
Checked November 18, 2026 on their own page
Drop-off
Goodwill of Central & Southern Indiana: donation drop-offFree
Goodwill stores take clothes, housewares, books, furniture and computers, but not mattresses.
Take donations to a Goodwill store during open hours and do not leave them after hours.
Checked November 18, 2026 on their own page
Greater Indy Habitat ReStore: donation drop-offFree
Four ReStores take usable furniture and appliances during store hours, and they can turn down items in poor condition.
Drop off Tuesday to Saturday, 10 a.m. to 7 p.m., at 4129 W Washington St or 7998 Centerpoint Dr in Indianapolis, 1099 N Avon Ave in Avon, or 1141 W US 40 in Greenfield.
Checked November 18, 2026 on their own page
Hamilton County: electronics and appliances at the HHW Drop-Off CenterCost varies
For homes in Carmel, Fishers, Noblesville, Westfield
The county drop-off center also takes household electronics and emptied refrigerators and freezers, with a $20 fee per TV.
Take it to 1717 Pleasant Street, Noblesville, Tuesday to Friday 8 a.m. to 5 p.m. or Saturday 8 a.m. to 1 p.m., with proof of residency.
Checked November 18, 2026 on their own page
Hamilton County: HHW Drop-Off CenterFree
For homes in Carmel, Fishers, Noblesville, Westfield
Hamilton County residents can drop off up to 200 pounds of household chemicals and paint a month for free with proof of residency.
Take it to 1717 Pleasant Street, Noblesville, Tuesday to Friday 8 a.m. to 5 p.m. or Saturday 8 a.m. to 1 p.m.; registering ahead is encouraged.
Checked November 18, 2026 on their own page
For homes in Indianapolis
Marion County residents can drop off paint, chemicals, propane tanks under 20 pounds and electronics, including TVs 27 inches or smaller, on set Saturdays.
Go 9 a.m. to 2 p.m. on the first Saturday (7550 N. Lafayette Rd.) or the second and fourth Saturdays (4925 S. Shelby St.); up to 20 gallons of liquid or 75 pounds of solids a visit, in see-through containers rather than trash bags.
Checked November 18, 2026 on their own page
What goes where
From each organization's own list of what it takes. Ask before you load the car if it's something big.
- Furniture
- Buy Nothing Project (local gift groups and app) · Greater Indy Habitat ReStore: free donation pickup · St. Vincent de Paul Indianapolis: free furniture pickup and drop-off · City of Anderson: heavy pick-up · City of Greenwood: monthly heavy trash · City of Indianapolis: heavy trash pickup · City of Westfield: Bulk Trash Day · Goodwill of Central & Southern Indiana: donation drop-off · Greater Indy Habitat ReStore: donation drop-off
- Mattresses
- City of Greenwood: monthly heavy trash · City of Indianapolis: heavy trash pickup · City of Westfield: Bulk Trash Day
- Appliances
- Buy Nothing Project (local gift groups and app) · Greater Indy Habitat ReStore: free donation pickup · City of Anderson: heavy pick-up · City of Greenwood: monthly heavy trash · City of Indianapolis: heavy trash pickup · City of Westfield: Bulk Trash Day · Greater Indy Habitat ReStore: donation drop-off · Hamilton County: electronics and appliances at the HHW Drop-Off Center
- Electronics
- Buy Nothing Project (local gift groups and app) · City of Westfield: Bulk Trash Day · Goodwill of Central & Southern Indiana: donation drop-off · Hamilton County: electronics and appliances at the HHW Drop-Off Center · Marion County ToxDrop
- Clothes and shoes
- Buy Nothing Project (local gift groups and app) · Goodwill of Central & Southern Indiana: donation drop-off
- Books
- Buy Nothing Project (local gift groups and app) · Goodwill of Central & Southern Indiana: donation drop-off
- Housewares and decor
- Buy Nothing Project (local gift groups and app) · St. Vincent de Paul Indianapolis: free furniture pickup and drop-off · City of Greenwood: monthly heavy trash · Goodwill of Central & Southern Indiana: donation drop-off
- Paint and chemicals
- Hamilton County: HHW Drop-Off Center · Marion County ToxDrop
Other areas, or the general guide:
- California: San Diego · Los Angeles · Ventura County · Santa Barbara County · San Luis Obispo County · Orange County · Inland Empire · Sacramento · Yuba-Sutter · Solano County · Bay Area · Central Valley
- Oregon: Portland · Willamette Valley · Bend · Medford
- Washington: Seattle · Spokane · Tri-Cities · Central Washington · Bellingham
- Nevada: Las Vegas · Reno
- Arizona: Phoenix · Tucson
- Colorado: Denver · Colorado Springs
- Utah: Salt Lake City · St. George
- New Mexico: Albuquerque
- Idaho: Boise
- Texas: San Antonio · Austin · Houston · Dallas-Fort Worth · Lubbock
- Georgia: Atlanta
- Missouri: St. Louis · Kansas City
- Nebraska: Omaha
- Illinois: Chicago
- Tennessee: Memphis · Nashville
- Florida: Miami
- South Carolina: Greenville
- New York: Buffalo
- Minnesota: Minneapolis-St. Paul
- Ohio: Cleveland
- Pennsylvania: Pittsburgh
- Louisiana: New Orleans
- Indiana: Indianapolis
Haven't had the sale yet?
Post it on our site for free, with printable signs and pictures for Facebook and Instagram. Once it ends, we'll email you the places on this page that serve your area.